I researched this hotel after finding the photo above. I found the following clips:
Charles Nye has accepted a position in the sample room at the Columbia Hotel.
A handsome street lamp was erected in front of the Columbia Hotel restaurant and dining hall.
- Logansport Pharos Tribune, 1893 May 26, page 4
"M. McTaggart has assumed the management of the Columbia Hotel and restaurant."
- Logansport Pharos Tribune, 1894 June 2, page 4
In 1896 Logansport Pharos Tribune reported that Arthur McTaggart was selling furniture and fixtures of the hotel Columbia.
1897 Logansport Times reported that Frank Beamer was now cooking at the Columbia hotel and lunch counter.
Baker & Anhier will open their new saloon in the Columbia Hotel tomorrow evening. An elaborate lunch will be served.
- Logansport Pharos Tribune, 1897 March 30, page 5
John Baker has improved and changed the interior of his bar room in the Columbia Hotel.
Louie Wandrei who recently purchased the lunch counter and dining hall at the Columbia Hotel has rearranged and refurnished the same in splendid style. He now has one of the neatest places of the kind ever opened in Logansport.
- Logansport Pharos Tribune, 1897 November 1, page 8
Fire reported Sept. 28, 1899 Logansport Pharos Tribune – Someone with murderous intent turned on two gas jets at the Columbia Hotel last night and but for the timely discovery by Mr. Wandrei a terrible explosion might have resulted. Suspicion rests upon a certain individual who had better make himself scarce.
Considerable furniture recovered from the Wandrei Columbia Hotel fire remains unsold and is now stored at 518 Broadway.
- Logansport Reporter, 1900 September 27, page 8